Ulster University Logo

Ulster Institutional Repository

The Spectre Returns:Conflicted Democracies,Truth Commissions and the Law

Biomedical Sciences Research Institute Computer Science Research Institute Environmental Sciences Research Institute Nanotechnology & Advanced Materials Research Institute

Campbell, Colm (2010) The Spectre Returns:Conflicted Democracies,Truth Commissions and the Law. Web Journal of Current Legal Issues, 1 . pp. 1-12. [Journal article]

Full text not available from this repository.

URL: http://webjcli.ncl.ac.uk/2010/issue1/campbell1.html

Abstract

Part of the self-identity of the liberal democratic state is a commitment to the ‘rule of law’. A paradox exists when a liberal-democratic state finds itself dealing with a legacy of serious systematic rights-violations. There is a further paradox when ‘transitional justice’ analyses are employed to deal with the conflicted ‘past’, since this discourse developed out of the need to deal with the legacy of authoritarian regimes in transition to democracy.The UK’s attempts to deal with Northern Ireland’s ‘past’ can be understood as the outworking of these paradoxes, and as driven by the need to comply with adverse rulings in relation to Art. 2 ECHR. This is the context for the ‘Report of the Consultative Group on the Past,’ which recommends a ‘Legacy Commission’ - in effect, a truth commission. The example suggests that transitional justice mechanisms can never fully be ‘outside’ the conflict, the legacy of which they examine. Assertions that particular international law framing is required contribute implicitly to a broader meta-conflict. While transitions involving authoritarian states can project straightforward narratives of change, those in the liberal state are unlikely to fit together so coherently, even if the level of violations is lower.

Item Type:Journal article
Keywords:transitional justice, truth commissions, amnesties, dealing with the past
Faculties and Schools:Faculty of Social Sciences
Research Institutes and Groups:Transitional Justice Institute
ID Code:15612
Deposited By:Mrs Elaine McCoubrey
Deposited On:14 Sep 2010 10:59
Last Modified:14 Sep 2010 10:59

Repository Staff Only: item control page