Ulster University Logo

Ulster Institutional Repository

Ill Met in Ghana: Jack Goody and Norbert Elias on Process and Progress in Africa

Biomedical Sciences Research Institute Computer Science Research Institute Environmental Sciences Research Institute Nanotechnology & Advanced Materials Research Institute

Liston, Katie/K and Mennell, Stephen/S (2009) Ill Met in Ghana: Jack Goody and Norbert Elias on Process and Progress in Africa. Theory, Culture and Society, 26 (7-8). pp. 52-70. [Journal article]

[img]PDF (Ill Met in Ghana: Jack Goody and Norbert Elias on Process and Progress in Africa) - Published Version
Indefinitely restricted to Repository staff only.


URL: http://tcs.sagepub.com/

DOI: 10.1177/0263276409348085


In recent years, Sir Jack Goody has published a series of essays (2002, 2003,2004, 2006: 154–79) criticizing Norbert Elias’s theory of ‘civilizing processes’.In all of them, Goody – himself a West African specialist – makes clear thathis disagreement with Elias dates back to their acquaintance in Ghana. Thedate is highly significant for it is unlikely that Goody’s opinions of Elias’sideas were initially formed by his reading of Elias’s publications. There werealso important differences between them in their approaches to theories oflong-term social development. Despite appearances to the contrary, Eliasand Goody have in fact much in common intellectually. Goody is one of themost historically orientated of anthropologists, and many points of contactwith Elias are evident in his work on literacy (1968, 1987), food (1982), orThe Domestication of the Savage Mind (1977). Both swam against theahistorical current of their respective disciplines and both rejected the oldnotion of ‘progress’. Elias’s fault is that occasionally his formulations mayappear to give the opposite impression. Goody’s fault, perhaps, is that – inspite of his own historical perspective – under any model of a structuredprocess he suspects there lurks a vision of progress and of Europeansuperiority.

Item Type:Journal article
Keywords:Key words civilization ■ Norbert Elias ■ Jack Goody ■ Naturvolk ■ progress
Faculties and Schools:Faculty of Life and Health Sciences
Faculty of Life and Health Sciences > School of Sport
Research Institutes and Groups:Sport and Exercise Sciences Research Institute
Sport and Exercise Sciences Research Institute > Centre for Sport in Society
ID Code:12327
Deposited By:Dr Katie Liston
Deposited On:11 Mar 2010 11:48
Last Modified:12 Feb 2014 12:10

Repository Staff Only: item control page